Trotsky: Study in the Thought by Ernest Mandel, New Left Books, £2.95р Revolution агу Marxism Mandel, New Left Books, $4.75p.
TROTSKY'S centenary will not be celebrated this year in Moscow Havana, Tirana or Belgrade. divides the old Stalinist family, the thought of Trotsky unites them. The founder of the Red Army, organiser of the October insurrection ultimate degeneration will be totally ignored in the land of his birth.
And yet it is Trotsky who is victorious. It is his. ideas (rather than those of his principal adversary Stalin) which continue to fascinate bourgeois historians and inspire revolutionaries to this very dav, it is his theoretical and political analyses which continue to guide the activities of revolutionary Marxists on a world scale. It is this fact (the decision taken by Trotsky to organise and distinguishes him from all the other opponents of Stalinism.
Ernest Mandel's two new books, produced by NLB to coincide with the Trotsky's birth, seek to accomplish a dual task. The Trotsky is an introductory work, designed to stimulate une rcader s appenie, lO serve as a footpath to Trotsky's Revolutionary Marxism Today is a critical interviews with Mandel some of the terriers of the Fourth International: Henri Weber and Denis Berger from France, Robin Blackburn and Britain and Jon Rothschild from the United States.
Mandel's response to the questions forces him to develop the ideas of Lenin and Trotsky. His interviewers refuse to let him retreat into the Marxist classics. both stimulating and iconoclastic.
Mande wil be forced to arguments cannot be ignored or dismissed out of hand.
Dynamic of His Today by Ernest or Peking, Hanoi Whatever else It fight back) that centenary of possible.
own writings. conducted by set of concepts:
Quintin Hoare from long-term And the combination is provocative, even Even those who disagree with gone concede his Mandel's Trotsky is compared on the bookjacket by NLB to Lukacs' Lenin. In one represent an assessment of Lenin and Trotsky as seen through the very special spectacles of leaders of the Fourth International and audacity of the young Trotsky who produced Marxist Trotsky realised that imperialism had created an economic Chinese Wall between nations, that no further country could join the understood before anyone else that accelerating created inequality on a planetary scale. The revolutions.
was pre-ordained that developed countries would follow the same path as the developed capitalist states. in sharp contrast to the 'Father of Russian Marxism', G.V. Plekhanov, who wrote at the same time: 'Russia stands at a crossroad on the way to capitalism and all other avenues are closed to her. In order to fight capitalism only one way is left... to help it grow as fast as But Mandel retuses to endorse any attempt to justify Trotsky's pre-Bolshevik organisational "In and of itself, there is nothing positive in Trotsky's stubborn opposition to Lenin's organisational concept of 1902-3; and the recent, belated attempts to rehabilitate it are ahistorical and sterile in character. Indeed the of "non-Bolshevism" between 1903 appear even more tragic today than they did at the time. They certainly made it much more difficult, between 1923 and 1928, to win the Bolshevik cadre to the key planks of his struggle against the bureaucracy. And if that cadre had OvOI majority Opposition, would have difference to world history.' Mandel's Trotsky is certainly the homage of the less This was deepen institutions.
the effect major importance fascism;
Trotsky's and 1917 The the Left made a great a disciple, but it is not uncritical. He refuses to accept the notion of infallibility as far as any of the classical Marxists are concerned. result is a compact and valuable introduction to the central ideas of Trotsky. vitalyou non-do marie roTskyism. Manders views are his own. They remain the subject of polemics (sometimes fierce) both inside and outside the Fourth International, but that in no •way. detracts from their value interviews were originally published in New Left Review (Socialist Strategy in the West and The Transitional Regimes in the East), but even these have been improved by the addition of supplementary questions and answers.
In his discussion of a revolutionary strategy in the West, Mandel refuses to accept that the defeats of the revolution are due solely to the • In most cases after the First World War, and sometimes even later in the 1930s or 1940s. the masses began to identify their democratic freedoms — which are an absolute gain that we aim not merely to defend but to consolidate and workers' bourgeois-democratic, parliamentary Although it is true that reformist leaderships bear overwhelming responsibility for this, they could nevertheless not have had they did without a conjunction of historical circumstances.
was the experience so too was that of Stalinism, through the reformist turn of the Comintern in 1934 and through the repulsive examples of the regimes of Eastern Europe and the USSR.
He argues that the experience of Portugal demonstrates, apart from other things, central importance of socialist democracy and insists that it has to form part of any viable revolutionary strategy in the West.
book contains two new interviews: Permanent Revolution in the Third World and The Politics of Contemporary Internationallism. Ine tirst consists of a sustained attempt by the interviewers to challenge the theses Permanent Revolution. They argue that the collapse of the European colonial empires and Mandel clarifies and enriches postulates of Trotsky's theses.
accepts thạt structural changes in process of industrialisation example, has industrial workers concetrations in Mandel describes countries remain excluded " industrialisation the world market.
the major imperialist states. specific Of of both proletarian power polemic. The sharp the with his political outlook.
But even those Renai. For compilation. attempt to understanding of world politics time. the establishment of juridically independent states compelled the national bourgeoisies to force through a limited industrialisation.
Thus some of the tasks ascribed by Trotsky to the proletariat have been carried through by the post-colonial bourgeoisie. What follows is an extremely useful and concrete discussion.
some of the He charts the changes that have occurred on a world scale. He there have been important Brazil, India, South Korea, Hong Kong, Mexico, Argentina. The Brazil, for created in Sao Paulo more than in most industrial the advanced capitalist these countries semi-industrialised rather than semi-colonial, but despite the persistence of his interlocutors, sountries. The bulk of repopulations bulk populations the process of The objective limits further industrialisation lie in the structure of The semi-industrialised countries remain subjected to the institutions and technology of The strategy of the permanent revolution remainitotally valid. • The increased weight of the proletariat in the 'third world' aids the transformation of struggles for national-democratic tasks into struggles. . for Mandel is at his best when he is engaged in a questioning therefore results in forcing him to confront issues not encompassed by orthodoxy'. Whether he does so successfully depends on whether one agrees who do not will find Marxism Today a unique it is the only sustained provide an internationalist Both of these books should be bought, read and studied. I think they will stand the test of
----- pull-quotes -----
Ernest Mandel Revolutionary Marxism Today
Ernest Mandel Trotsky